Current Issue
BB Past Issues
A Note From Marcy
Complete Recipe Index
Subscribe to BB
Subscriber Sign In
Free BB Classics
About Us
Contact Us
When Bakers Write - Features
Scent of A Baker
Music and Dance
Product Reviews

(c) A Marcy Goldman, BetterBaking.Com Original Recipe

Fruitcakes Revisited, a short history and love affair

Everything you need to know about fruitcakes - their history and amazing legacy and a guide to some of my famous fruitcake recipes including Black Cake and Apricot Brandy Fruitcake, in A Passion for Baking, Oxmoor House, 2007 and The New Best of, Whitecap Books 2009, respectively.

Fruitcakes from the Baker
What You Don't Know Will Impress You *

Marcy Goldman’s Fruitcake Feature ©

*Or promote a new found respect for the cake you love to hate.


Carrot Cake Fruitcake in Recipe Archives
  I am going to spare you the usual fruitcake jokes (bricks, door stoppers et al) and cut to the  high ground. Fruitcakes are deserving of some reverence in the culinary collective, if only due to the fact that they are quite beyond tradition - they hedge on antiquity itself. To follow the trail of how fruitcake came to be is a poor man’s course in the evolution of modern baking.   Fruitcakes go way, way back - to the Crusades, if not before. There is evidence the early Romans made cakes of fruit, nuts and wine and ‘receipts’ for Scripture Cake - boldly biblical in name - is another indication of fruitcake legacy. Fruitcake’s predecessor may well have been something similar in flavor but quite different in form. It was panforte - an item you may recognize this as a gourmet shop item increasingly available at holiday time. Panforte (pronounced pan-a-forteh) originated as a dense, low-slung convection and literally means ‘strong bread”. (Try biting into some imported paneforte, you will see immediately why the name stuck.) Panforte was the granola or trail bar, so to speak, of the Crusaders. Made with citron and cinnamon, as well as the Middle Age’s beloved honey, spice-laden panforte conveniently traveled well and tasted ambrosial. So much so that it survived not only the Crusades but beyond a few millenniums and today, the sweet Christmas treat is imported from Sienna, Italy where a panforte industry not only exists but thrives.    My baker’s logic takes this a step further and seems to me that panforte beget fruit puddings or at least are kissing cousins to fruit puddings which in turn were probably the precursors of modern day fruitcake. Fruit puddings, made of similar ingredients (flour, spice, candied fruits) were made stove top - steam cooking pre-dating traditional oven baking. THEN…..another big thing happened, yeast came along and ovens and together, they conspired to transform fruit puddings into fruited breads which got sweeter and fatter and made their way into - datah! fruit cake. Fruit cakes were made at home but as many things were, many, many years ago, brought for baking to the village baker who kindly obliged. Oh - right. Forgot to mention. After yeast came baking powder around 1850, an invention (originally called yeast powder) which was made fruited breads (such as Scottish Bun) into cake - vastly changing the texture, taste, crumb, and concept of fruit bread. What remains is that fruit cake’s legendary longevity. Claims of 100 year old fruit or wedding fruitcakes abound - tales of those who have nibbled a slice are less rampant.

Fruit cakes stayed ensconced in Britain, Australia and New Zealand but somehow we North American colonialists merely tolerate it. Aside from several references to ‘Martha Washington’s Great Cake’ - a cholesterol and calorific wonder of 40 eggs and four pounds of butter, which comes up in several vintage American cookbooks, most prized fruitcake recipes hail from Britain. Aside from this being a palatial issue, to my mind, this lack of respect is entirely due to places like hardware stores and pharmacies, bless ‘em all, selling less-than-stellar fruitcakes, pretty well killing the notion that fruitcakes can be sheer delight.

The controversy continues with protests that candied fruits are just insufferable, or the evils of marzipan or royal-icing crusted wedding fruitcakes. Not to mention, and this is something more and more people will declare and food writers get het up about: there is simply no more cake in fruitcake…it is simply fruit with a tablespoon of spiced up batter holding it together. In any event, I am unashamed to admit that fruitcakes are still adored by us professional bakers. We see it as a special event that marks our calendar along with Buche Noel (which is the so-wholly Gaelic ‘take that’ response of French pastry chefs) - an occasion to go all out and produce the most replete, fruitcake ever - awash in brandy or whiskey, lovely candied fruits and a heady batter of butter, fresh eggs and flour.   Aged fruitcake preparations begin now - and both the pros and home bakers alike, pride themselves on their special fruit and spice mix. In fact, nothing brings out the testosterone in the average baking grandma then asking what constitutes a better fruitcake. Like dark of light fruitcake? With jam or a grated apple or two, white or brown sugar, macerate fruit before or not, brandy, wine, rum or naught, green cherries nor only red, nuts or not, baking powder or none, coat with apricot jam or a overcoat of marzipan or just cheesecloth soaked spirits?   Well. How to please everyone. Easy. If you have a family fruitcake recipe you adore, turn this page. If not, and you think you hate fruitcake, preheat your oven. Three recipes - Aged (aka Traditional Medium Fruitcake, not dark, not light: medium), Ageless (aka Fruited Tea Brack - no aging required, low end, a lovely tea cake and New Age (aka Golden Apricot Pecan Fruit Cake - good aged or not - for candied fruit loathers - bound together with a lashing of Triple Sec of Cointreau).  So - choose a fruitcake. Tuck into some or simply tuck a slice under your pillow. Either way, it’s staying stuff.

My favorite fruitcakes such as Apricot Brandy Fruitcake or my famous Black Fruitcake (circa Emily Dickenson) are nestled in The New Best of (Whitecap Books, 2009), and A Passion for Baking (Oxmoor House, 2007) both available at and Passion for Baking (Oxmoor House, 2007)
My most recent fruitcake is a gorgeous Chocolate and Sour Cherry Fruitcake Carrot Cake Fruitcake and is available at

© This is a Marcy Goldman/ original recipe
This recipe is for sole, personal use of visitors of BetterBaking.Com Online Magazine. Marcy Goldman/ recipes are for your enjoyment but not to be posted or reprinted without express permission of the author/baker. Thank you kindly for respecting my copyright and happy baking. BetterBaking.Com, established 1997.
Printer-Friendly VersionRecommend This Page